After a somewhat provocative tag-team student post
got quite a few American Studies students all "Reilled"-up and a little bit "Mad", I thought I'd recycle parts of this post
I first wrote many years ago (check out the exact date -- talk about an artifact
-- it's the month before the presidential election!). The question that today's blog post poses has been hotly debated in my own department and I am not surprised that a group of such thoughtful (and largely respectful
to each other) students would take it up, on their own!
I had read an article from the Chronicle of Higher Education
(the link is now broken, unfortunately) which references a recently published book, Closed Minds? Politics and Ideology in American Universities
, written by three faculty members from George Mason University
. If you read the students' post, part of the discussion focused on how appropriate it is when teachers reveal their political perspective**
. Would that action have an inappropriate effect on their students? Would it amount to, as one student argued, being "indoctrinated"?
|Does this guy look like me? Or Doc OC? Ah, who can tell the difference, anyway!|
The book's authors state that based on their 2007 study, the majority of professors "say they keep their own politics out of the classroom". In fact, only a minority of college faculty (28%) admit that they openly reveal their political bias to their students.
But even if the above statistics are true, does it even matter if teachers conceal their political leanings?
Another study, conducted by two professors from Pennsylvania State University
may have the answer. In their research-based article, "I Think My Professor Is a Democrat
", they published two related findings, based on student surveys:
- College students agree that most professors do not reveal their political bias (thus corroborating the findings from the book mentioned at the beginning)
- But 75% of students were able to guess correctly their professor's political leanings, anyway.
Finally, the biggest question looming behind this particular discussion: if the great majority of college professors call themselves liberal, does this influence their students to become more left-leaning as well? The same researchers conducted another study which found that students started shifting slightly to the left under both Republican- and Democrat-voting professors -- not just under liberal-leaning teachers.
What do these studies mean for our class discussions (online and off)? What could be responsible for the shift to the political left? Perhaps, too, there is a difference between college-level classrooms and high school with regard to these findings?
**For students who want to hear "both sides" of every issue (assuming "both sides" are equally meritorious), my own philosophy has always been (quoted from Howard Zinn): "You can't be neutral on a moving train." I guess I'd rather be upfront with my views than play guessing games all school year-long.